
BD Maestro Pvt. Ltd. v. Great Galleon Ventures Ltd.
On 3 November 2026, Hon’ble Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav pronounced a 246-page judgment disposing of seventeen commercial suits together. The lead matter is ABD Maestro Pvt. Ltd. v. Great Galleon Ventures Ltd., CS(COMM) 987/2026. Every plaint was returned under Order VII Rule 10 CPC for want of territorial jurisdiction. In more than half of them, neither party had any presence in Delhi.
Those of us who file IP suits will have seen this coming. Still, the judgment is worth reading closely, because it does more than return plaints. It tells us which of this Court’s own precedents it considers binding and which it doesn’t, and it adds a forum non conveniens filter that did not exist in this form before.
The Court’s starting point
The opening paragraphs are unusually frank. The Court accepts that it has long exercised something close to pan-India jurisdiction in IP matters, and that having done so, drawing a line now is not easy. It frames the problem as one of institutional discipline. If a dispute belongs elsewhere and is brought to Delhi almost forcibly, the natural forum loses the chance to decide it. It cites Aligarh Muslim University and ONGC v. Utpal Kumar Basu for the point that a court’s standing suffers when it entertains matters with only a trivial link to it.
The banyan tree remark is the one people will quote. Delhi, the Court says, gives shelter to Indian IP law but also stunts what grows beneath it.
What the Court actually held
Infringement and passing off are separate causes of action. If a plaintiff pleads both, jurisdiction must be shown for each, and clubbing them does not cure a defect in one (Dabur India v. K.R. Industries, Dhodha House).
On “carries on business”, the Court goes back to Patel Roadways, Sanjay Dalia and Ultra Home. A company with one office carries on business there. With several, the principal office is ordinarily the registered office. A subordinate office counts only where the cause of action arises, and in that case the company cannot instead sue at its principal office. The Court also deals with a pleading habit many of us know: a GST certificate describing Delhi as a “principal place of business”. The Court says that is a defined term under the GST Act and is not the expression used in Section 20(a) CPC.
For passing off, the cause of action arises within a forum only if the defendant has sold goods bearing the impugned mark there, and those must be commercial sales to distributors, wholesalers or retailers. Availability of goods does not do it. A sale by some unconnected firm that is not the defendant’s agent does not do it either.
For offline infringement, what matters is the defendant’s use of the mark in the course of trade within the forum. Registration of the mark in a particular place is not part of the cause of action.
For online infringement, Banyan Tree governs. The plaintiff must show that the defendant specifically targeted persons in the forum, that the plaintiff suffered injury there, and that commercial transactions were actually concluded through the website with users in the forum. The transaction requirement may be relaxed only where Sections 134(2) and 62(2) are not available to the plaintiff and the defendant has no presence in India at all.
Which precedents the Court set aside
This is where the judgment is most likely to be tested on appeal or by the larger Bench. A co-ordinate Bench has already referred these questions (Hindustan Unilever v. Kwick Living, 25.08.2026). Relying on Ashok Sadarangani, the Court says a pending reference leaves no vacuum and urgent matters must still be decided.
It then goes through the line of cases one by one. WWE v. Reshma Collection is said to have departed from Dhodha House and to be unworkable after Sanjay Dalia and Ultra Home, so the later Division Bench rulings built on it “may not be binding”. Burger King, on passing off, was decided without reference to Glen Raven Mills and Indovax. The Division Bench in Tata Sons v. Hakunamatata had treated a website’s “looming presence” and accessibility as enough for targeting. The Court says that cannot stand with Banyan Tree, which refused to replace purposeful availment with purposeful avoidance, or with the UK Supreme Court in Lifestyle Equities v. Amazon UK (2024 UKSC 8), and it holds that the reasoning has no precedential value. The Court also notes that Machinenfabrik Rieter and Reiter AG limited the bar on trap transactions to the online world, although Banyan Tree itself relied on offline authorities.
Investigators, effects and drafting
The Court treats an investigator set up by the plaintiff to find jurisdiction as, in the ordinary case, concocting it. There are two exceptions. One is where, without the investigator, no cause of action could be maintained before any other court. The other is where sales in the forum are plainly taking place and the investigator only supplies evidence, for instance by buying from Delhi retailers and stockists whom the defendant has supplied. Applying Section 39 of the Sale of Goods Act, delivery to the plaintiff’s own agent or carrier is treated as delivery to the plaintiff, and the Court says this applies beyond passing off.
The argument that the effect of infringement is felt where the plaintiff sits is rejected. It would make the amendments to Sections 134(2) and 62(2) pointless.
Quia timet suits get a tighter test. The defendant must have shown a deliberate intention to act, the act must be imminent, and the plaintiff must stand to suffer substantial if not irreparable prejudice. For regulated goods, the Court asks whether the defendant holds the licence needed to sell in that State. An excise licence for liquor, or a licence under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act or the Insecticides Act, are the examples given. Without it, a claim that the defendant is about to enter Delhi is hard to sustain.
On demurrer, the Court says the old rule that the plaint is taken as true has weakened. Bald averments unsupported by documents can be ignored when jurisdiction is in question.
Forum non conveniens
For the filing bar, this may be the most important part. Even where a plaint is maintainable under the CPC or the special provisions, the Court can decline to entertain it. The question is whether the material, integral and essential part of the cause of action arose in Delhi, or only a slender, incidental part. The inquiry is confined to the plaintiff’s own pleaded facts, save in exceptional cases.
The illustrations in the judgment are worth reading in full. A quia timet suit after a defendant announces a Delhi launch will ordinarily be entertained if the threat is real. A suit where goods are sold pan-India, including Delhi, may not be, because manufacture, packaging and labelling elsewhere are a much larger part of the cause. Where both sides are outside Delhi, the plaintiff’s bona fides in leaving its own forum may be questioned. A purchase from Flipkart or Amazon delivered to a Delhi address does not make Delhi the forum conveniens, since the plaintiff could have placed that order from anywhere. For online content, the place of uploading is the forum conveniens, and if that cannot be found, the place where the plaintiff resides or carries on business.
The Court also deals with restaurant bookings taken from Delhi, social media analytics showing Delhi traffic, and Delhi-based pro-forma defendants such as intermediaries or domain registrars. None of them confers jurisdiction.
What should be done from now(my suggestion)
Plead the connecting facts and annex the documents for them. A line saying the product is freely sold in Delhi, with no invoices or memos behind it, is what this judgment calls an empty averment. If both parties are outside Delhi, be ready to say why Delhi and not the plaintiff’s home court. Plan any trap purchase around the two recognised exceptions, and prefer evidence of ordinary supply to Delhi retailers. And use Sections 134(2) and 62(2) where they are available. Parliament gave the plaintiff that choice for a reason, and the Court is plainly telling us to use it.
Whether the larger Bench keeps this framework is the open question. Until it rules, this is the approach single-bench IP courts in Delhi will apply.
Always at your service.
Neeraj Gogia
#TrademarkLaw #IntellectualProperty #DelhiHighCourt #BrandProtection #IndianLaw #TrademarkInfringement #LegalAwareness #AdvocateLife #IPRights
